handdator

Visa fullständig version : Effekt av snabb el långsammare viktnedgång på kroppssammansättning hos elitidrottsmän


King Grub
2011-09-08, 08:58
When needed, athletes are recommended to have a gradual weight loss (WL) of 0.5-1 kg·week-1 through moderate energy restriction. However, the effect of WL rate on long-term changes in body composition (BC) and performance has not been investigated in elite athletes.

PURPOSE:

To compare changes in body mass (BM), fat mass (FM), lean body mass (LBM) and performance 6 and 12 months after two different WL interventions promoting loss of 0.7% versus 1.4% of body weight·week-1 in elite athletes.

METHODS:

Twenty-three athletes completed 6 and 12 months post-intervention (slow rate (SR), n=14, 23.53.3 yrs, 72.212.2 kg and fast rate (FR), n=9, 21.44.0 y, 71.612.0kg). The athletes had individualized diet plans promoting the predetermined weekly WL during intervention and four strength-training sessions·week-1 were included. BM, BC and strength (1RM) were tested baseline, post-intervention and 6 and 12 months after intervention.

RESULTS:

BM decreased by ~ 6% in both groups during intervention, but were not different from baseline values after 12 months. FM decreased in SR and FR during intervention by 313 vs. 234% respectively, but were not different from baseline after 12 months. LBM and upper-body strength increased more in SR than in FR (2.01.3% vs. 0.81.1% and 122 vs. 62%) during intervention but after 12 months there were no significant differences between groups in BC or performance.

CONCLUSION:

There were no significant differences between groups after 12 months, suggesting that WL rate is not the most important factor for maintenance of BC and performance after WL intervention in elite athletes.

Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab. 2011 Aug 29. Long-term effect of weight loss on body composition and performance in elite athletes.

PatJack
2011-09-08, 09:07
Intressant. Kanske man vågar labba med mer -kcal då.

aijou
2011-09-08, 09:17
Så ska man dra slutsaten att, i det långa loppet, så påverkar inte hastigheten som man går ner i vikt muskelmassan nämnvärt (I detta fall)? Beror detta i så fall på att man har mer tid på sig att jobba upp muskelmassan om man deffar hårdare men kortare perioder?

Jag brukar vara ganska dålig på att tolka dessa abstrakt (eller vad man kallar det). Även om detta var ganska straight forward. Men mycket intressant läsning.

EDIT: Sen gäller antagligen inte samma sak för elitatleter jämfört med oss hobby-byggare.

Eddie Vedder
2011-09-08, 09:19
Abstraktet nämner ju inget om styrketräningsvana dock. Det framgår att de är "athletes" men inte hur länge de har styrketränat.

aijou
2011-09-08, 10:52
Abstraktet nämner ju inget om styrketräningsvana dock. Det framgår att de är "athletes" men inte hur länge de har styrketränat.

Sant. Det måste ju spela in väldigt mycket på resultatet.

TheIsh
2011-09-08, 11:29
Vad är en atlet på elitenivå i det här fallet? "Elite athelte" avslöjar ju inget om deras träning, det kan ju handla om curling.

Pipharen
2011-09-08, 13:30
Det var en lång deff.

Sniggel
2011-09-08, 21:09
"FM decreased in SR and FR during intervention by 313 vs. 234% respectively"

Huh? De blev av med 313 respektive 234% av deras fettmassa under dieten?
Nu är jag nog för trött för att förstå vad de menar. Återkommer imorgon.

Eddie Vedder
2011-09-08, 21:15
"FM decreased in SR and FR during intervention by 313 vs. 234% respectively"

Huh? De blev av med 313 respektive 234% av deras fettmassa under dieten?
Nu är jag nog för trött för att förstå vad de menar. Återkommer imorgon.

Jag läste det som 31,1 och 23,4 men du har ju rätt, finns inga decimaler där. Det måste väl ändå vara en miss?

Springer
2011-09-08, 22:25
Det var lite "lost in translation" över det hela. Här är alla tecknen på plats!

http://journals.humankinetics.com/ijsnem-in-press/ijsnem-in-press/long-term-effect-of-weight-loss-on-body-composition-and-performance-in-elite-athletes

"Context: When weight loss (WL) is needed, it is recommended that athletes do it gradually by 0.5–1 kg/wk through moderate energy restriction. However, the effect of WL rate on long-term changes in body composition (BC) and performance has not been investigated in elite athletes. Purpose: To compare changes in body mass (BM), fat mass (FM), lean body mass (LBM), and performance 6 and 12 mo after 2 different WL interventions promoting loss of 0.7% vs. 1.4% of body weight per wk in elite athletes. Methods: Twenty-three athletes completed 6- and 12-mo postintervention testing (slow rate [SR] n = 14, 23.5 ± 3.3 yr, 72.2 ± 12.2 kg; fast rate [FR] n = 9, 21.4 ± 4.0 yr, 71.6 ± 12.0 kg). The athletes had individualized diet plans promoting the predetermined weekly WL during intervention, and 4 strength-training sessions per wk were included. BM, BC, and strength (1-repetition maximum) were tested at baseline, postintervention, and 6 and 12 mo after the intervention. Results: BM decreased by ~6% in both groups during the intervention but was not different from baseline values after 12 mo. FM decreased in SR and FR during the intervention by 31% ± 3% vs. 23% ± 4%, respectively, but was not different from baseline after 12 mo. LBM and upper body strength increased more in SR than in FR (2.0% ± 1.3% vs. 0.8% ± 1.1% and 12% ± 2% vs. 6% ± 2%) during the intervention, but after 12 mo there were no significant differences between groups in BC or performance. Conclusion: There were no significant differences between groups after 12 mo, suggesting that WL rate is not the most important factor in maintaining BC and performance after WL in elite athletes."

Sniggel
2011-09-09, 06:23
Skulle verkligen vilja ha fulltexten nu. Jag förstår inte om SR dietade i 12 månader och FR i 6 mån eller om båda grupperna dietade i 12 månader (det låter dock ologiskt med tanke på resultatet).

Genomgick FR 6 månaders diet och väntade sedan tills SR var klara med sin diet eller började SR 6 månader i förväg?

Någon som har tillgång?

edit: Nej så länge dietade de inte förstås om jag räknar lite. 6% förlust BM borde gjorts på cirka 4 veckor i FR och cirka 8 för SR.

Ok så de testades 6 och 12 månader efter dieten och då såg man inga skillnader efter 12 månader. De hade väl kanske gått upp igen till sin vanliga matchvikt antar jag :p